Live Happy's Logo

Written by : Live Happy •

Transcript – The Hidden Beliefs That Shape Your Happiness With Nir Eyal

Follow along with the transcript below for episode: The Hidden Beliefs That Shape Your Happiness With Nir Eyal

[INTRODUCTION]

[0:00:04] PF: Welcome to Live Happy Now, where we explore the science and stories that help us live with more joy, resilience, and connection. I’m your host, Paula Felps, and each week we sit down with experts and everyday heroes who show us how happiness grows when we put it into practice.

Examining our beliefs can transform the way we see the world and even change how we relate to the people we care about. This week, I’m joined by best-selling author Nir Eyal, whose new book, Beyond Belief, shows how our unquestioned beliefs quietly shape our behavior, our happiness, and our ability to persist through life’s challenges. Join me as he explains how beliefs influence our motivation, our emotional responses, and the suffering we unintentionally create for ourselves. Let’s dive in.

[INTERVIEW]

[0:00:50] PF: Nir, thank you so much for joining me on Live Happy Now.

[0:00:52] NE: Oh, Paula, it’s a real pleasure and an honor. I’m so glad to be here with you.

[0:00:55] PF: Oh, we’ve been trying to make this work. The audience has no idea what we’ve gone through. We keep trying to make our schedules work. And so I’m glad that it finally came together and we’re able to have this conversation.

[0:01:05] NE: Me too. Me too.

[0:01:06] PF: So you’ve released a fantastic book called Beyond Belief.

[0:01:09] NE: Thank you.

[0:01:10] PF: Oh, my gosh. It’s so good, and it’s so timely. Before we dig into what it’s all about, tell us a little bit about your backstory of how you became so interested and aware of the power of beliefs.

[0:01:24] NE: Yeah. So I write books about struggles that I have myself. I’m not one of these authors that tells you what they know. I write because I have questions I want to know. And I’m bringing the reader along on that journey. My friend Gretchen Rubin says, “Research is me search.” And that is so true.

So I spent six years trying to figure out the answers to the questions I had with this book. And the Genesis came out of a kind of a funny phone call. Several years ago, I had this phone call with a reader of one of my last books, Indistractable. And they called me up, and they said, “Hey, I read Indistractable. It was a great book. I really enjoyed it, but it didn’t work for me.” And I said, “Oh, that’s interesting. Tell me more. Because I spent six years on that one as well. I’ve got 30 pages of peer-reviewed studies in the bibliography. It changed my life. I really want to know. Let’s go step by step and figure out where it didn’t work for you. Let’s start with step one. How did step one go?” And they said, “Ah, you know what? I read step one. I read it. I definitely read it. It’s just that I didn’t do it.”

[0:02:27] PF: That is different.

[0:02:27] NE: I said, “Okay, I understand. Okay, fine. Let’s go to step two. How did step two go?” “Yeah, I remember step two. Step two was super interesting. I really enjoyed it. It’s just that I didn’t do that one either.” And I was kind of racking my brain here. How is it that people would sometimes wait for months to tell the author of a book that they had read that the thing that they didn’t do didn’t work?

And at first, I thought, well, is this guy crazy? Is it me? Did I write a bad book? What happened here? Then I realized, “Wait a minute, wait a minute. I do this all the time.” I have loads of books that I’ve read and haven’t put into practice. I’ve watched the YouTube videos and the podcast episodes, and I have paid gurus and experts that gave me great advice that I haven’t put into practice. Why? And I think this is one of the seminal questions of our age when we have so much information. I mean, there’s no secrets anymore. If you want to know how to do something. Read a book, ask Google, ask ChatGPT. It’s all out there.

Why is it that, despite having all this information, why don’t we all just achieve our wildest dreams and our greatest goals? What separates those who accomplish their goals and those who don’t? And it turns out that it’s not intelligence. It’s not even resources. A lot of people who have every advantage in the world accomplish very little. And some people who start from the bottom and have every disadvantage go on to do amazing things. It’s certainly not skill. Skill can be learned. Information can be acquired. So what is it? So why don’t we do what we know we need to do?

And so that was kind of the central question. If we have classic economics says that in order to get someone to do something, in order to motivate someone, you have to know what to do, the behavior, and you need the benefit, classic incentives model. But that can’t be all there is to it. We know if it was crazy, we would have six-pack abs and be multimillionaires, but that’s clearly not what’s going on.

What’s missing is that motivation is not a straight line between behavior and benefit. Motivation is a triangle. That, in order to sustain motivation – and that turns out to be the seminal, most important trait of someone who accomplishes their goals. It’s just persistence. It’s not intelligence. It’s not resources. It’s persistence. That turns out to be what studies find is the most important trait. It’s not that persistence guarantees success, that quitting guarantees failure.

If persistence is so important, how do we persist? Well, we stay motivated. Well, how do we stay motivated? We have to understand that in order to sustain motivation, we need not only the behavior- knowing what to do. We not only need the benefit, why we’re doing it. But most importantly, what sustains motivation is belief. That if I’m working for a boss who I don’t believe has my best interest at heart, I don’t believe they know what they’re doing, I don’t believe they’re going to give me that raise, that promotion I deserve, am I going to stay motivated, am I going to persist for that person? No, I’ll slack off and probably quit at some point.

Conversely, if I don’t believe in my own ability to do a behavior, maybe if I tell myself, “I’m not cut out for this. I’m not ready. This is too hard. Who do I think I am?” I’m also not going to persist. In order to sustain our motivation over the long term, we have to have not only the behavior, not only the benefit, but most importantly, the belief. That’s what holds it all together. And so that’s what Beyond Belief is all about.

[0:05:29] PF: So when we talk about beliefs, tell us what you mean. What’s the difference between belief and a fact or even faith? Because you make a distinction.

[0:05:40] NE: Absolutely. So we use this word kind of interchangeably. When I say I believe this, I believe that, it’s kind of a synonym for fact, but a belief is not a fact. A fact is an objective truth. It is something that is true whether or not you believe in it. So the world is more like a sphere than it is flat. I’m sorry if you have any flat earthers in your audience. The world doesn’t care what you believe. A fact is a fact. Facts are objective truths. You cannot change facts.

The other end of the spectrum is faith. Faith is a conviction that does not require evidence. God rewards the righteous. There’s no amount of evidence that’s going to convince someone not to hold that faith, nor should it. It’s a matter of personal faith, right? Between fact and faith is something very special. And that’s what we call a belief. A belief is a conviction that is open to revision based on evidence. Conviction that is open to revision based on evidence.

And what’s so magical about these beliefs, why I think they’re so important, is that unlike faith, which people almost never change, unlike facts, which you cannot change, beliefs are malleable. We can choose our beliefs. And that’s what makes them so powerful. The most important discovery I made in the book, and these reams of research that I looked through, really boils down to this, that beliefs are tools, not truths. Beliefs are tools, not truths. We keep hanging on to these beliefs, thinking that they are facts when they’re not.

And I think most of our problems in the world, whether it’s personal problems, interpersonal problems, geopolitical problems, all come from the same cause. It’s that people don’t recognize that they’re thinking of their faith as a fact when it’s not. Just a matter of faith. And they don’t recognize that the things that they think are facts. Many of them are just beliefs. And so if we can distinguish between the three and, most importantly, pick the beliefs that serve us rather than hurt us, even if we don’t know if they are true, that’s the big kicker. Even if we don’t know they’re true. Because beliefs are tools, not truths.

[0:07:39] PF: So where do our beliefs come from? Because I think your book really made me start re-evaluating what do I believe. Because we go through life and we don’t really have to think about it. We know we think or we believe something. So tell us where these beliefs come from.

[0:07:56] NE: Well, that’s a huge compliment what you just said that the book made you evaluate where do your beliefs come from and are they serving you. Because most people never, for their whole lives, pause and ask themselves that very question. Because all of our beliefs come from somewhere. It’s either from our childhood, from our culture, from something somebody said to us that we’ve repeated time and time again until we act like it’s true.

So now that we recognize that we don’t have to keep carrying these beliefs, we can choose them. That means that we can stop, ask ourselves, “Hey, is this belief that I keep carrying around with me, ” it’s like a big, heavy sack that you’ve been carrying for years and years, “is it really a fact? And does it serve me? Or could I change my belief? And what would that do for me?” That’s, I think, a huge revelation that the beliefs you have are not your fault, but they are your responsibility.

[0:08:50] PF: I love that. And where do we even start with examining our beliefs, thinking about what we believe? I think especially now in this climate, there’s a lot of very strong opinions that we might adopt as beliefs.

[0:09:05] NE: We start with ourselves. We need to understand where the suffering in our life comes from. And that’s really the goal of changing your beliefs. What we find is that when we have these limiting beliefs, what’s the definition of a limiting belief? A limiting belief is a belief that saps your motivation and increases your suffering.

So if you believe that that person is an idiot because of their political views, or because it’s your mom, or because it’s your angry neighbor, or whatever, what does that do to your motivation to work on that relationship? It lowers it, right? What does that do to your suffering? It increases it.

The goal is not necessarily to change people’s minds. If you are waiting to ease your suffering based on what other people think and do, don’t hold your breath; you’re going to suffocate. Happiness doesn’t work that way. And we need to recognize where our suffering actually comes from. Where does suffering come from? Where does suffering live? I know you’re a happiness expert, but let’s look at the opposite, the things that make us unhappy. Where is suffering? Suffering is not out here. Suffering is not because of what’s going on in the world. Suffering is not because of what other people are doing or what they think or what they believe. Suffering happens here. All suffering happens here. Where else could suffering exist?

And so it’s very important that we understand that suffering is real, but it’s also a judgment. That is the source of all suffering. And this isn’t new. I didn’t invent this. This comes from Stoicism. It comes from Buddhism. Many traditions for a very long time have said this. It’s just that now science is catching up with what philosophy has said for quite a long time: that there’s a big difference between pain and suffering. And what moderates the two turns out is belief. And so it’s not that we should be passive. It’s not that we shouldn’t fight for things to improve in the world, for justice. Absolutely, we should stay committed to those things. And the only way I think we can stay committed is to increase our motivation and decrease our suffering.

I talk to a lot of people who are very altruistic, who are trying to help the world, and they tell me about all the problems, and they’re totally burned out because they associate what they’re doing with suffering, right? That how can people believe that? And how can people treat others the way they do? And how can we do this and that? It’s so terrible. And they’re completely deflated, and they’re completely unmotivated because they’ve attached what those people are doing as a judgment that they should suffer from themselves.

Whereas when they have a liberating belief that says, “Good, I’m glad that person disagrees with me. Amazing. Now I get a chance to test my own beliefs. Maybe this is an opportunity to practice patience. Maybe I’ll learn something, right?” So changing those beliefs from limiting beliefs to liberating beliefs is really the core of separating pain from suffering and sustaining motivation long enough to actually make a difference in the world.

[0:12:01] PF: And where do we start doing that? Because first we have to examine what we actually believe and then re-examine whether or not that serves us.

[0:12:12] PF: We’ll be right back with more of Live Happy Now.

[0:12:20] PF: And now let’s hear more from Nir Eyal.

[0:12:24] NE: I would start with: where is the suffering in your life? That’s where we start. And no suffering is too big or too small. I worked with a lady the other day who said her suffering- what was on her mind was that morning she was stuck in traffic, and she was with her child, and she got very annoyed in traffic. And she said a few things that she did not want to say in front of her child. And it was causing her suffering that she couldn’t control her emotions when she was stuck in traffic. Kind of a petty example.

I’ve seen a woman use some of the techniques I describe in the book who was suffering from terminal brain cancer. I mean, talk about something that you think would be justified to suffer from. And she transcended her suffering using some of these techniques. So where we started, we ask ourselves, where are we suffering? It could be a relationship. It could be a New Year’s resolution that you don’t know why you’re putting off year after year. It could be some kind of dream deferred. It could be something that is causing you an annoyance in your life. Maybe it’s, “I hate that my political opponents disagree with me. How can anybody believe the other side is right?” It could be something as simple as that. Anywhere you are suffering in your life. You want me to give you a very personal example?

[0:13:33] PF: Please do.

[0:13:35] NE: Yeah, sure. So in my life, one of my longest-held beliefs was that my mother is very judgmental. She’s just a very hard-to-please person. And I probably have some brothers and sisters among your audience who empathize with me because they have –

[0:13:51] PF: You’re going to have a fan club here real quick.

[0:13:53] NE: Yeah, exactly. So a few years ago, I wanted to do something nice for her. And it was her birthday. And so I wanted to send her some flowers. The problem was I was in Singapore, and she was in central Florida where I grew up. And sending flowers from literally the other side of the planet, not so easy. I had to stay up till 1 am. I called the best florist I could find. I found the best bouquet I could afford. And I made sure that they arrived on time. And I was sure that my mom was going to tell me what an amazing son I am. That’s not what happened.

What happened, Paula? No, that’s not what happened. What happened was I call her up the next day. And I say, “Hey, Mom, happy birthday. Did you get the flowers I sent?” To which she says, yes, “I got the flowers. Thank you. But just so you know, they’re not that nice. In fact, they’re half dead. So don’t order from that florist again.” To which I said, “Well, that’s the last time I buy you flowers,” or something like that. And I’m not happy I said it. I regret it. But that’s what came out.

Now, my wife, who is also my editor, she’s on the cover of the book, she knows all my research, and she heard the entire conversation. She turns to me, and she says, “Nir, would you like to do a turnaround on that?” To which I said, “No, I do not want to do –”

[0:15:04] PF: I am happy with my answer.

[0:15:05] NE: Exactly. Thank you. Because you know what? I need to vent. I’m not going to do your touchy-feely hocus pocus. I need to vent. That’s what we’re told. When someone hurts our feelings, we need to speak our truth. We can’t keep it inside. We need to vent about them, right?

Well, in fact, the research literature shows that that’s wrong. That when we vent about people, we’re doing nothing but reinforcing our beliefs about them. Because we don’t see people as they are. We see people as we are, as we believe them to be. So you’re just reinforcing this patina of a person, not who they actually are.

I put that aside. I took my wife’s advice. I took out a piece of paper, and I did a turnaround. And here’s what a turnaround is. And I’m happy for folks to follow along if they want. I’ll be the guinea pig here. A turnaround is a technique that comes from inquiry-based stress reduction. And it’s been validated in many studies to be a very, very effective way to ease your suffering. And I found it to be an absolutely life-changing practice.

And here’s how inquiry-based stress reduction works. Some of you might recognize it from the work of Byron Katie. She actually was working, she was channeling a technique actually that’s been with us for over 2,500 years. You can see a direct line from different people who have used this technique all the way back to Aristotle 2,500 years ago. And so what the technique asks us –

[0:16:16] PF: So you’re saying it has a bit of a track record is what you’re telling.

[0:16:18] NE: It has a bit of a track record. Yes, but I think it’s one of the most underutilized techniques. I mean, it is true. I do this sometimes five, six times a day. It’s so helpful in my life. So inquiry-based stress reduction asks us first, first thing you do is you ask yourself, “Where are you suffering?” Okay, it could be no suffering is too big or too small. Where’s the suffering in your life? Maybe it’s a relationship, maybe it’s a dream deferred, maybe it’s whatever’s annoying you, causing you suffering in any shape or form in your life. Just write that down and then ask yourself why. Why is that causing you suffering?

I’ll give you an example. In my life, what is causing me suffering is my mom. Why? Because she is really judgmental and hard to please. Okay, now we have four questions to ask ourselves. The first question is, is that why true? My mother is too judgmental and hard to please. Is it true? That’s question number one. Paula, let me ask you: when someone sends you flowers from the other side of the planet, the appropriate response is?

[0:17:14] PF: Thank you. They’re beautiful.

[0:17:14] NE: This is why we’re good friends. Exactly. Thank you, Paula. Clearly. It’s a fact my mom was being too judgmental and hard to please. Who says that? You say thank you, and that’s it. You don’t complain that the flowers weren’t nice enough. Okay, let’s go to question number two. Question number two: is it absolutely true? Is it absolutely true? It sounds like the first question. It’s not exactly the same. Is it absolutely true? Can I be 100% certain, no doubt whatsoever, that the reason I am suffering is because my mother is too judgmental and hard to please? There’s no other reason. Can I be 100% absolutely sure that that is true?

[0:17:52] PF: Interesting.

[0:17:53] NE: I can’t be 100% sure. There might be some other reason. Okay, fine. Third question. How do I feel or who do I become when I hold on to that belief? So if you wrote down your why, ask yourself, how do I feel when I hold on to that why? Why am I suffering? My mother is too judgmental and hard to please. When I held on to that belief, I felt bad. I felt short-tempered. I felt anxious. I didn’t feel like myself.

Okay, now the fourth and final question. Who would I be without that belief? Again, if you close your eyes and you just let that belief dissolve, just imagine that belief doesn’t exist anymore, how do you feel? Well, for me, when I imagine that, just to pretend, what would it feel like if that belief disappeared? I felt lighter. I felt physically lighter. I felt less anxious. I felt less stressed. I felt more like the person I wanted to become. So now, in just four questions, I realized that the thing I was sure was a fact wasn’t a fact. It was just a belief that holding onto it was causing me suffering and that letting it go made me feel way better.

And now it’s time for the turnaround. The turnaround asks us the most important question, which is: could the opposite be true? So take your why that you think is causing your suffering, okay? I’m suffering because I’m stuck in traffic. I’m suffering because my mom is annoying. I’m suffering because I have a brain tumor. And ask yourself, could the opposite be true? Such a simple question. Could the opposite be true?

So I’ll be the guinea pig again. My mother is too judgmental and hard to please. That’s why I’m suffering. Could the opposite of that also be true? What’s the opposite? My mother is not too judgmental and hard to please. Could that be true? Well, she did say thank you for the flowers, didn’t she? And she was just saying a statement of fact. The flowers weren’t so nice. And she was just giving me advice so that I wouldn’t get scammed by this florist. So maybe, just maybe, she was trying to be helpful, not hurtful. Could be. Could be true. I’m not saying it is true, but it could be true.

Okay, let’s do another turnaround. The opposite of my mother’s two judgments on hard to please could be: I am too judgmental and hard to please. How could that be true? Well, wasn’t I the one who had stayed up till one in the morning rehearsing verbatim exactly the words of praise that I deserve to hear, telling me what a great son I was? And when I didn’t get those words of praise exactly as I deserve to hear them, I lost it. So who was being judgmental?

Okay, now there’s a fourth turnaround. The opposite of my mother is too judgmental and hard to please could be I am too judgmental and hard to please towards myself. Well, how could that be true? Well, that actually turned out to be the most true because the more I thought about it, when this thing that I planned and spent a lot of time and money on didn’t work out the way I wanted it to, I felt bad. I felt incompetent. I felt like I’d messed up.

And this is what we call a very important concept in psychology. This is called misattribution of emotion. A misattribution of emotion is when we feel crummy on the inside, and so we attribute it to something on the outside. Can you believe what she said? I can’t believe he did this. Did you see what’s happening in the world today? Did this happen? This war, this thing. That is all happening out there. The suffering is always happening up here in your head. Always. Suffering is not happening out there. It’s always happening in your head. And that’s what I was doing to my mom. I was attributing the way I felt inside to her as the cause.

Now, I have four beliefs. Okay, I started with one. Now I have four other beliefs, okay? Which one of those is true? Which one is false? All of them? None of them? Who cares? Who cares? We spend so much time arguing. When you said this, you meant to do that. These aren’t facts. They’re just beliefs. It’s perception. They’re completely subjective. So it doesn’t matter. which one is true and false. What matters is which one serves me and which one hurts me. Beliefs are tools, not truths.

The first belief that the only way I could be happy was if my mom would change because my mother is too judgmental and hard to please. So for me to stop suffering, she had to change. Now, Paula, you haven’t met my mom. I’m telling you that ain’t going to happen. Because, as we said earlier, when you wait for other things to change outside of you so you can finally stop suffering, don’t hold your breath; you’re going to suffocate.

The other three beliefs I could do something with. Now, does it mean we have to be best friends? Does it mean we have to have picnics in the park every day? No, it doesn’t mean any of that. It just means I no longer have to suffer in my relationship with my mom. And so now I’m much more motivated to work on that relationship. Who the heck wants to be in a relationship with someone who’s judgmental and hard to please? Nobody. So now I’m more motivated to work on that relationship, and I don’t have to suffer in that relationship. It doesn’t mean I’d have to be around her every day. That’s not the goal of this exercise. It’s just a way to unlock what’s already within you: this ability to have greater patience, to have greater ability to be the person you actually want to be, as opposed to being enslaved by this cage of your own creation that is created by your limiting beliefs.

[0:23:08] PF: That is fascinating. And I wonder how it changes what we focus on when we change those beliefs.

[0:23:18] NE: Yes, absolutely. I mean, the evidence is overwhelming that beliefs change what we see, what we feel, and what we do. And I’m not speaking figuratively. I’m literally speaking here that what you believe will change how you perceive reality. We know that people who are on a diet see food as larger, that people who are afraid of heights see distances as further away, that I can show two people the exact same image and one will see squares and one will see circles. It’s called the Coffer Illusion. You can look it up for yourself. This is totally based on our background, on our beliefs, what we’re experiencing. So we like to say that I’ll believe it when I see it.

Actually, the exact opposite is true: you see what you believe. And so that’s very, very important because we need to realize that we don’t see reality accurately. One of the myths, one of the lies that the brain tells us, is that you see things as they really are. You absolutely do not see things as they are. And if you can’t see reality clearly, why do you think you can see others’ perspectives clearly? You can’t. You can’t even see your own reality clearly. So we need to have much more intellectual humility about our ability to induce what we think others intend in their lives because we don’t even know ourselves how reality is accurately portrayed.

[0:24:41] PF: That is so incredible. It’s just one more example of some of the great information that you have packed into this book. You have a lot of powerful insights and true, genuine, deep wisdom in Beyond Belief. So what is it that you hope every reader takes away from this book?

[0:24:58] NE: Yeah, a few things. So number one, that we do not see reality clearly. None of us can. It’s impossible. There’s just too much information. And so your brain doesn’t see reality as it is. It sees reality as it believes it to be. So I want everyone to have the intellectual humility to realize that we don’t see reality clearly. We see it filtered by our beliefs.

Number two is that you are capable of far more than you know. And what you are capable of is not based on the fact that you can do what you can do, but actually that you can do what you believe you can do; you are limited by your beliefs. And that finally, that your beliefs dictate your reality. Not everyone’s reality, but how you perceive reality is dictated by your beliefs. And so if you change your beliefs, you change what you feel, what you see, what you do, and ultimately who you become.

[0:25:50] PF: Fantastic. Nir, thank you so much for spending time with me today. We’re going to tell our listeners how they can find you, how they can find the book.

[0:25:56] NE: I appreciate it very, very much.

[0:25:58] PF: You’ve got it. Thank you so much.

[0:26:01] NE: Thank you.

[0:26:06] PF: That was Nir Eyal talking about the power of our beliefs. If you’d like to learn more about Nir, check out his books, follow him on social media, or download his free 5-Minute Belief Change Guide; just visit us at livehappy.com and click on this podcast episode.

That is all we have time for today. We’ll meet you back here again next week for an all-new episode. And until then, this is Paula Felps reminding you to make every day a happy one.

[END]


In this episode, you’ll learn:

  • How examining our beliefs allows us to approach relationships with more clarity and compassion.
  • How to identify limiting beliefs that increase suffering and sabotage motivation.
  • A simple, evidence‑based technique for transforming painful beliefs into empowering ones.

 

Visit Nir’s website

Discover his book, Beyond Belief.

Download Nir’s FREE Five-Minute Belief Change Guide.

 

Follow Nir on social media:

 

Don’t Miss a Minute of Happiness!

If you’re not subscribed to the weekly Live Happy newsletter, you’re missing out! Sign up to discover new articles and research on happiness, the latest podcast, special offers from sponsors, and even a happy song of the week. Subscribe for free today!

Sign up for Live Happy‘s Sunday Sillies newsletter.

Interested in advertising or partnering with us? Complete this quick form.

Don’t miss an episode! Live Happy Now is available at the following places:

Apple podcast icon Pandora Icon Audible Icon IheartRadio Icon

(Visited 41 times, 1 visits today)